Awaiting ae recommendation meaning

Awaiting ae recommendation meaning. The EiC gives the final verdict based on the AE's recommendation. Now it is almost 3 weeks. Apr 21, 2020 · You have three queries. Checking central formatting requirements, e. At the third day, I saw Awaiting EE Decision which is still there. 1. Now, the status has changed to ‘Awaiting Admin Final Processing’ from ‘Awaiting EIC Decision. Making a recommendation. Will the readers of this particular journal find this Aug 3, 2021 · Now, coming to your question, it appears to be a good sign that your manuscript is moving ahead in the peer review process, that too at a reasonable pace. Good or bad sign? Jan 18, 2020 · A status change from AE Assigned to AE Review means that the manuscript has been picked up by the AE for review. 11. This decision should take into consideration your own opinion of the submission as well as the general consensus of the refereeing committee. " Sep 8, 2022 · We submitted a paper to a journal roughly 3 months back, the paper remained under review for almost 2 months, after which upon enquiry to the AE, we received a reply that one review has been completed while the other is pending due to certain reasons. Awaiting Reviewer Jul 19, 2018 · Usually, if a submission is not a good fit for a specific journal or falls short of its standards, a decision of desk rejection is communicated to the author. Once the completed reviews comes in, the Associate Editor (AE) evaluates them and gives his recommendation to the EiC. ” There are four decision options: . Jun 15, 2020 · How do I interpret rapid changes between the 'Awaiting Technical Editor Scores' and 'Awaiting AE Recommendation' statuses? Indicators of acceptance in highly trusted journals As indicated at the beginning, there are several aspects to consider for a topic such as this. ’ We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. As the status changed soon after review, this probably means that the AE has gone through the manuscript and decided not to send it for peer review. The peer review process can be broadly summarized into 10 steps, although these steps can vary slightly between journals. 2. For 2 weeks, the submission status was showing ‘Awaiting admin processing’. Article. 5. If so, it seems to have gone from this decision to awaiting a decision by the Editor-in-Chief (EiC). To get to the AE recommendation tab, go to your Associate Editor dashboard by clicking “Associate Editor Center” in the top gray bar or from under the “Manage” dropdown in the top gray bar. Understand the journal and case study peer review process and read our tips for revising your submission. Explore what’s involved, below. After this, the manuscript usually goes through a formatting check by the journal staff before it is assigned to an editor. It means that the peer review is over, taking about two months, and the peer reviewer recommendations are awaited on the paper. To access the site, click the link within the e-mail or enter the web address (URL) in Sep 14, 2019 · “Awaiting SE Recommendation” means that it went to a Section Editor (SE) of the journal for checking the match with that section of the journal. A plagiarism check. TMI allows reviewers three Dec 4, 2016 · The speak 'recommendation' is used cause the AE does not give the final resolution: he/she can only recommend the Editor-in-chief (EiC) include this matter. While, I am still waiting, no reply. An author-readable brief paragraph outlining the basis of recommendation is necessary. Under review also can mean that the article is being considered by the science editor for technical and English language check or it is with the subject editor and he is evaluating it for external review, or the article is peer review by selecting the “Recommendation without Review” option. After peer review, the editor will consider feedback from the reviewers and then make a decision about the article. According to the process described in IEEE Transactions, "Awaiting AE recommendation" status means that the AE has collected all reviews from the reviewers who were assigned to review your manuscript and that the AE's decision for acceptance is pending. The Manuscript Status on ScholarOne displays “Waiting for Reviewers’ Scores” if one or more agreed reviewers have not submitted their scores. Apr 26, 2023 · (5)Awaiting Reviewer Scores: AE开始送外审，AE首先要邀请若干数目的外审专家，给他们发审稿邀请函，直到凑齐足够数目的接受审稿邀请专家那一刻，评审状态才会变为Awaiting Reviewer Scores. Awaiting Admin Checklist. You may then make your preliminary decision that will be sent to the Editor-in-Chief. What does this mean? Oct 31, 2017 · The status of my submission changed from Admin: Not Assigned to EA: [name] plus Awaiting ED assignment plus Awaiting CE decision at Scholarone manuscripts. #3. Answer: Thank you for your question! When a manuscript is submitted, it undergoes editorial assessment. Peer reviewers are given 2 weeks to submit their review of your article. 10. Last week, the status changed to Awaiting AE Recommendation. 31 awaiting eic decision 2021. On the occasion that a reviewer withdraws from the process, the Editorial Team will begin the reviewer selection process again. I guess, awaiting recommendation status has been shown after the completion of a review process, in that case the editor might be busy to look through the comments of the reviewers, or the 6. After almost three weeks of being in Awaiting Reviewer Assignment, the status has changed to Awaiting Reviewer Selection. This stage could be called as "Awaiting AE assignment", wherein the manuscript is evaluated for ethical considerations and scope match with the readership of the journal. The AE will now go through the manuscript to check for things such as a match with the scope of the journal, the quality of the writing, and even the novelty of the study. There are three basic types of decisions: Accept, Revise, and Reject. No matter which decision you receive, be sure to read the entire decision letter carefully. In april, they got back To us with "major revisions" needed. Monitoring the review process. Yes, it could be rejected. Checking compliance with length requirements, if any. SEs, after considering the recommendation of the AE and the input from reviewers, make the sole determination about which papers are published, which papers will be returned for revision, and which papers will not move forward in the review cycle. Mar 28, 2020 · The status ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation’ means that, based on the peer reviewer (or technical editor review, in this case), the AE is making a decision on the paper. Peer Review and Decision Process. As per my understanding, the status should be Awaiting EIC Decision. Oct 27, 2023 · Meaning: Manuscript Submitted: This means the author has successfully submitted and approved the manuscript. Can someone please let me know what they actually mean? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. But it could also have other outcomes, including requesting revision. However, today, it changed back to Awaiting Referee Scores. The manuscript status has changed from "awaiting reviewer scores" back to "under review". What happens when you receive the decision letter? After peer review, the editor will consider feedback from the reviewers and then make a decision about the article. Now in February, 2022, I resumitted the manuscript. Since the book have come in, the AE should ideally not take too long to give his recommendation. See also this question: Manuscript status changed from “Reviews completed” to “Editor assigned”. ’ What does this status change mean? Should I consider Mar 14, 2022 · I submitted a paper to a journal that uses the ScholarOne submission system. Your article has now received the minimum number of reviews required to make a decision. So, the status of my paper was "Awaiting reviewer scores" since one month and it turned to "Awaiting editorial decision" last Friday. ’ Please help me understand these status changes. , line numbers, if required by the journal. Associate Editor の指名待ち. ’ Asking find me understand these status changes. I got my paper rejected within two days after that. If it is sent out to reviewers, then the status changes to Awaiting Reviewer Scores. Management Science Awaiting AE Recommendation. “Awaiting final decision” means that now, the manuscript is indeed with the Editor-in-Chief, who is in the process of coming to a decision of acceptance with major/minor revisions Understanding the Decision Process . Eic usually signifies the Editor in chief. If it’s just been one day, then it means the journal is assigning it to an AE, or the AE is evaluating it to send for review or to desk reject. 3. The GE, as the name suggests, is an external editor and is assigned when the journal cannot find an Under review means the AE is currently evaluating whether the paper is worth sending out for review. Awaiting AE recommendation The paper received the sufficient number of reviews (usually 2) and, on their basis, AE makes recommendation to EIC Apr 21, 2020 · You have three queries. We revised it and submitted it after a week. Jun 7, 2020 · What does mean awaiting AE recommendation? The status ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation’ means that, based on the peer reviewer (or technical editor review, in this case), the AE is making a decision on the paper. Under 'Awaiting AE Preliminary Decision', you will the list of papers for which you can draft a decision. Still the status is same. Odds are this means the AE changed. Then I submitted the revised manuscript in 10 days. But, quickly after this, the status changed to “awaiting EIC decision” within 2 weeks and Making a Paper Recommendation. Associate editors are guided by the recommendations of reviewers, but 4 days ago · 2021. Sep 16, 2021 · Are you a student at a higher institution or an early-career researcher who is striving to understand and master the peer review process so to increase the odds of getting a paper published in the Journal of Forestry Research or another reputable, peer-reviewed, scientific journal? In this paper, a young, senior editor provides a handbook of the peer review process based on his decadal Nov 21, 2016 · The status of my manuscript is "Awaiting AE decision", and it has lasted for nearly four months. Mar 31, 2021 · What does awaiting AE mean in a journal? 1 Answer 1. Awaiting AE Assignment. In such cases, the manuscript is not sent for peer review. Now the status has changed to ‘Awaiting ED recommendation’. We asked them to reconsider, and they accepted our appeal. Since it appears that the peer reviewers were contacted for review, it is possible that the manuscript is not desk-rejected. In this stage, the Associate Editor (AE) evaluates the suggestions of the peer reviewers and gives his/her recommendation to the Editor-in-chief (EiC). Now for the last 2 weeks, it's showing awaiting EIC. 9e33. This stage lasted one day and now, I am waiting for the final decision. 該当論文の「Make Decision」タブにアクセス。. Sep 18, 2020 · About the statuses, here’s what they mean (as you may probably know too). (For most journals, the associate editor is referred to as the AE. Apr 23, 2020 · Because ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ means that the manuscript passed the admin and/or Associate Editor (AE) check and was awaiting peer review. Don't make assumptions. After submitting the revised article for a week, a ADM was assigned and the status has changed to "awaiting reviewer invitation. 28 in review process 2021. There are several decisions that authors may receive after submitting their paper to one of the Society’s journals: Reject without review: The Action Editor has rejected the paper without sending it for peer review. Does it mean that is under the review of editorial office? Could it change from Awaiting AE assignment to Under Review directly without AE being assigned ? Could Sep 6, 2011 · Jun 15, 2009. Mar 23, 2021 — Prod means pending recommendation form will use of awaiting reviewer Does awaiting ae for your assumptions of reviewers scores mean that aes is pnas pending recommendation to awaiting ae assignment reporter. However, in your case, it is not very clear whether the paper was sent 6月 27, 2018 Knowledge. The criteria of reviewer selection can be based on: (a) The direct knowledge of people who work in the same field (b) Various searches The peer review process. It seems that the Associate Editor (AE) felt it could fit into a particular section of the journal. Also, ‘SAE’ perhaps stands for ‘Specialist Associate Editor. Answer: The change in status from 'Under review' to 'Pending recommendation' implies that the peer review of your paper is complete and the Associate Editor or Editor-in-Chief will check the reviews and give his/her recommendation on acceptance, rejection, or further revision. Selecting and assigning reviewers. In the month of December, I got a "reject and resubmit" decision. Select the paper, then click on “Take Action. Accepted as is: A recommendation to publish the manuscript in its original form. After one round of flawless revision [needed by the] reviewers, associate editor (AE), and Editor-in-Chief (EIC), [the ‘awaiting’ status seems to be] over. " Does it mean that my paper will go through another round of review with new reviewers? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Find a paper in the AE Dashboard, “Awaiting AE Recommendation” queue. I have submitted my paper and the system is ScholarOne Manuscript. Sach said: My PI submitted a manuscipt to a journal in January. So, why has it returned to the referee(s) after last week's status? Also known as with editors (APS), review completed, required reviews completed (Elsevier Editorial System (EES)), awaiting AE recommendation, awaiting decision (ScholarOne), awaiting EiC decision (IEEE), Editor Decision Started (AIP), Decision Started (NPG), or pending decision (Bioinformatics Oxford journal). So based on what you say, and I hope I'm wrong, but it looks like the AE won't be sending your paper to reviewers. Mar 27, 2015 · AE means it is awaiting associate editor recommendation. ’ The following day, it changed back again to ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation. The journal peer review process. Notes: The Manuscript Status on ScholarOne displays “AE assigns reviewers,” if the number of agreed-reviewers is less than four. The AE then conveys their decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who makes the final decision. Awaiting Reviewer Selection. C. 査読者の選出待ち. The SE is the final decision maker in reviewing submissions for MISQ. I have sent two pieces of mail to AE to inquire of the status, but I have not received any reply. Once review comments are returned to the editors, the associate editor assimilates them and makes an editorial recommendation regarding publication, revision, or rejection. Jun 5, 2017 · This makes me think that the paper has not yet been sent for peer review. Awaiting Admin Processing: Your submission is waiting for initial review by the editorial office. Why are you responding to a thread that is Dec 19, 2017 · I submitted a paper to some journal. The decision letter is delivered to the author via email. Within less than two months it came for minor revision. Selecting and Assigning Reviewers. I have previously published in the same journal and it had taken 5 months to Apr 23, 2018 · Hi all, I want to ask a quick question related to publication process. Dec 5, 2017 · I have submitted a paper to a very reputed publication of electrical engineering via ScholarOne. You may notice that an AE makes a “recommendation”, not a “decision”. Aug 4, 2018 · Three weeks ago, I submitted my paper to a social sciences journal with impact factor. Dec 15, 2021 · Home - Study Catch Oct 9, 2020 · I had sent an article to an SCIE journal using the ScholarOne manuscript system. Mar 25, 2016 · It is difficult to estimate how big longer you necessity up stay. What does this change mean? Does it mean that one of the selected reviewers has declined the invitation? Is it a bad sign? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. After two and half months the status got changed from awaiting reviewer scores to awaiting recommendation. AE (Associate Editor) によって決定されたRecommendation を一旦取り消す必要がある場合、以下の方法で、再度「Awaiting AE Recommendation 」の状態に戻すことができます。. The word 'recommendation' is used because the Awaiting reviewer assignment Reviewers decide if they accept or decline the invitation (in the second case AE invites another reviewer). According to the process described in IEEE Transactions, “Awaiting AE recommendation” status means that the AE has collected all reviews from the reviewers who were assigned to review your manuscript and that the AE’s decision for acceptance is pending. I am not entirely clear about the wording of the latest status. It said "Awaiting AE recommendation" for a while under status. If the Editor-in-Chief does not agree with the AE’s recommendation, the Editor-in-Chief may return the manuscript to the AE and ask the AE to obtain additional reviews. 管理者による論文チェック待ち. May I know is there any chances for at least to get a major revision. This is deliberate terminology: it is the Editor-in-Chief (EiC) who makes the decision, whereas the AE merely recommends an outcome. 28 awaiting ae recommendation 2021. Click on “Save as Draft” or “Submit. Initial Check. But all of a sudden, instead of moving to "Under Review", the status changed to "Awaiting AE Recommendation". 9. Select “Reject” as your recommendation and enter comments to the editor AND author in the AE Recommendation form. 21 awaiting reviewer scores 2021. Congrats on your first submission! Dec 4, 2016 · 1 Answer to this question. Click into that category, then click into the manuscript. Jun 12, 2020 · These stand for the associate editor and guest editor respectively. 1 conditionally accepted with mandatory major change (4 weeks) (Two reviewers, one of whom did not agree to accept the review, should be the reviewer of the previous round. Mar 25, 2016 · Answer: It is difficult to estimate how big longer you necessity up stay. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Checking the Reviews Mar 15, 2016 · Difference between a recommendation and a decision. Mar 16, 2022 · I submitted manuscript in October, 2021. Go to AE Center > Papers > In Progress from the administrative toolbar. Editor Feedback: “Reviewers should remember that they are representing the readers of the journal. g. Thus, it seems that the AE is taking a decision on your paper whish he/she will pass on to the Editor-in-chief (EiC). Oct 8, 2015 · AE stands for Associate Editor. It may include for example: Checking for missing or broken files. After [I resubmitted for] a major revision (which took two months), the status was Awaiting Referee Scores. ” Select a recommendation, then write in your comments to the EiC and Author. What does this situation mean? What should I do? . Once initial check up is done on your manuscript, the EIC will screen your manuscript to check if it fits the scope of the journal and if it is of sufficient interest to the journal's readership. ' You will also how this ebook Aug 15, 2015 · I submitted my paper to a journal twelve days ago. Nov 12, 2018 · The status "Awaiting reviewer assignment" indicates that the editor has sent out reviewer invitations. Once the AE sends aforementioned recommendation to one EiC, aforementioned status will change to 'Decision in process. Just now it says "awaiting EIC decision". So, the reviewers will share their comments with the Associate Editor (AE) along with their recommendations for the paper – whether (or not) they believe the paper has merit and should therefore be considered (or not) for publication. Aug 9, 2022 · The paper stayed in the "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" stage for around three months. Awaiting reviewers scores simply mean the article is with the reviewers and the journal office is waiting for the comments. Answer: The change in status from 'Under review' to 'Pending recommendation' means that peer review of your paper is done and the Associate Editor (AE) will now go through the reviews and give his/her recommendation on whether it should be accepted, rejected, or revised. ) A manuscript can have either an ED (AE) assigned or a GE, not both (unless this is for a special issue). By November it showed awaiting EIC decision. 30 awaiting co-eic recommendation 2021. May 6, 2021 · I revised the paper accordingly and addressed the feedbacks. Share. When you have submitted your paper or case study, up to three experts in the field will review it to provide validation, quality control and added value to you in the form of constructive feedback. In Manuscript Central, there were some changes of the paper’s status during the first two days, and as far as I can remember, these were Awaiting ADM Processing and Awaiting technical editor selection. It then moved to ‘Awaiting reviewer selection’ and stayed at that stage for 9 days. May 25, 2020 · Answer: Hello Jyotirmayee – welcome to the forum! To get right into it, your (seniors’) understanding of the ‘Awaiting EiC Decision’ in ScholarOne's Manuscript Central (called ‘Decision in Process’ in some other systems) is correct to some extent. Mar 9, 2022 · The editorial hierarchy varies from journal to journal. It is rare for manuscripts to be recommended “as is” in the first round of review. Awaiting Final Decision: This is the decision by the Editor-in-Chief (EIC). During reject and resubmit, I got comments from 2 reviewers, and Feb 26, 2021 · I have submitted a manuscript to a ScholarOne journal. The Editor-in-Chief (EiC) makes the final decision on manuscript, with the associate Apr 12, 2016 · Decision making processes may vary across journals, but generally speaking, for papers that are sent out for review, the final decision is usually taken by the EiC. Once the requisite number of reviewers (generally 2 to 3) accept the invitation, the status changes to "Awaiting reviewer scores" which is the equivalent of "Under review. This step is usually performed by the journal's administrative staff. Next, suitable referees are selected based Then, changed to Awaiting AE rec. The paper stayed in the "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" stage for around three months. AE stands for Associate Editor. Papers that pass the initial screening are then sent to a panel of reviewers (usually two or three). Relax, the whole process takes months. If the status of a paper number is marked Paper Review Completed, you can proceed to read the review (s) and make a recommendation to the Journal Editor. Meaning of ‘Awaiting Editor Assignment’ This means that your manuscript has cleared the admin check, that is, it was found matching the journal’s scope and also adhering to the journal’s guidelines, apart from a cursory check of the novelty and quality of the study. Economist. Reject: The paper has been through the peer review process and the Action Peer reviewers are given 2 weeks to submit their review of your article. Based on these factors, the AE will decide whether or not to Mar 28, 2020 · My manuscript status changed from ‘Awaiting Technical Editor Scores’ at ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation,’ but an same time, this went back to ‘Awaiting Technical Editor Scores. Oct 24, 2020 · This is quite simple. First "Awaiting Reviewer Score (s)" for a while and then "Awaiting AE Recommendation", which lasted only a few days before becoming "Awaiting DE Decision". This is probably a duplicate, but I won't mark it as such since my vote would be definitive. Jan 19, 2021 · What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Does "Under Review" mean that the paper has passed the editorial check? What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses Nov 21, 2022 · The paper stayed in the "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" stage for around three months. Mar 29, 2022 · The duties of an AE are the same for every assigned paper and include: 1. This will bring you to the View Papers page where you will be able to view the papers Each journal’s site has a unique web address that should be provided to you by your site Admin via e-mail. Feb 17, 2021 · No revisions because it is already "Awaiting AE recommendation". He will then assign a AE or an academic editor who Mar 28, 2020 · My manuscript status changed from ‘Awaiting Technical Editor Scores’ to ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation,’ but the same day, it went back to ‘Awaiting Technical Editor Scores. Let’s take them one by one. . Decision notification e-mails and what they mean. The final decision can made by the EiC. This is based on the AE’s recommendation. You will see a category for papers awaiting the AE recommendation. "Awaiting recommendation" means the manuscript's peer review process has been completed, and the handling editor has sent such manuscript to the chief editor to decide whether to reject, or accept Feb 28, 2021 · My paper underwent a revision. Generally, the status 'Evaluating recommendation' is used when the AE is making his/her recommendation on the paper. Answer: Ideally, the status "Evaluating recommendation" should not take more than a few weeks. There is no oracle for such things. This could be because the original AE declined the assignment, resigned from the editorial board, is too busy to make a decision, and so on. bProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) Information for authors. The status of my paper changed from "Awaiting AE assignment" to "Under Review" directly. Awaiting Editor Decision. Nov 26, 2021 · 1 Answer to this question. Comment. 「Recommendations」の項目の一番 SE Role. 投稿SCI杂志，等待AE建议已一个月，是否催稿？知乎上有科研人员分享投稿经验和审稿流程，帮你解答疑惑。 Oct 27, 2023 · Meaning: Manuscript Submitted: This means the author has successfully submitted and approved the manuscript. May 29, 2022 · 2021. The ME or AE (Associate Editor) can only make a recommendation to the EiC, but the decision can be communicated only after the EiC approves, irrespective of whether it is an Jul 30, 2021 · 3. This is not an unusual process and is encountered with Admin Dashboard （管理者ダッシュボード）に表示される査読プロセス中の論文ステータスは以下の通りです。. Awaiting reviewer scores Reviewers are working on their reviews. Feb 21, 2019 · 2. Jul 19, 2017 · 1 Answer to this question. ql sj jv qv cf li ca hf cw vk